“She was one of the most talented singers we had,” Lopez also said “I’m still shocked.”
Lopez went onto say that she can’t understand why Toscano was voted off. And she’s certainly not alone, when Toscano’s name was announced as the one to be eliminated the audience’s reaction was to shout “no”.
The other judges also expressed their surprise at the vote. Randy Jackson said ‘I’m with Jennifer, all in shock. You were one of the best singers in this.’
But Steven Tyler went further, telling America that their “lack of passion was unforgivable.” Twitter also had a rush of messages expressing the same outrage and shock at the news. So where did all the votes come from when there was such collective outrage at the results.